By Dr. Macie Smith
Choosing the right care setting for your loved one can be challenging and emotional, especially when they can no longer live safely and comfortably in their own home. Two common options you may come across are nursing homes and assisted living facilities. While both provide care and support, they may cater to different needs and offer different levels of assistance. Understanding the differences between these two types of facilities is important in making an informed decision when planning for your loved one’s long-term care needs.
What is Assisted Living?
Assisted living facilities are designed for seniors who need some help with activities of daily living (ADLs) but do not require intensive medical care. These facilities offer a blend of independence and support, allowing residents to maintain a relatively active lifestyle. Services typically include:
• Personal Care Assistance: Help with bathing, dressing, grooming, cooking and other daily activities.
• Medication Management: Assistance with taking prescribed medications on schedule.
• Housekeeping and Laundry: Regular cleaning services and laundry assistance.
• Meals: Nutritious meals are provided, often with options for special dietary needs.
• Social Activities: A variety of recreational and social activities to keep residents engaged and active.
• Transportation: Scheduled transportation for shopping, medical appointments, and other outings.
• Customized Care: A few levels of care are usually provided, and residents can pay more if more intensive care is needed.
Some assisted living facilities even offer specialized programs for people with Alzheimer’s and dementia. It’s important to note that in order to qualify for most assisted living communities, residents must require assistance in at least one area of their ADLs.
What is a Nursing Home?
Nursing homes are also known as skilled nursing facilities. This type of facility is intended for people who require constant medical care and supervision. These facilities provide a higher level of care compared to assisted living and are staffed with medical professionals, including registered nurses (RNs) and licensed practical nurses (LPNs). Services in the nursing home usually include:
• 24/7 Medical Care: Continuous monitoring and medical care for chronic conditions and serious illnesses.
• Rehabilitation Services: Physical, occupational, and speech therapy to aid recovery and improve quality of life.
• Specialized Care: Care for residents with specific conditions such as Alzheimer’s, dementia, or post-surgical needs.
• Personal Care Assistance: Help with daily activities similar to those in assisted living, but often at a more intensive level.
• Meals and Nutrition: Dietitian-approved meals tailored to specific health requirements.
• Social Activities: Recreational and therapeutic activities designed to engage residents and improve their well-being.
Key Differences
• The Level of Care: Assisted living facilities are suitable for individuals who need help with daily activities but are generally in good health, while nursing homes are designed for those who require ongoing medical care and supervision due to serious health issues.
• Independence: Assisted living promotes independence with support available as needed, whereas nursing homes provide comprehensive care, often reducing the level of independence.
• Environment: Assisted living usually has a more home-like setting with private or semi-private apartments. Nursing homes are more institutional, with shared rooms and common areas for people to use.
• Staffing: Assisted living facilities are staffed with caregivers, aides, and sometimes nurses depending on the location, but not to the extent of nursing homes. Nursing homes are staffed with licensed nurses and other medical professionals providing around-the-clock care.
• Cost: Assisted living is generally less expensive than nursing homes due to the lower level of medical care and supervision needed. Nursing homes have a higher cost due to intensive medical services and specialized care.
Making the Right Choice
When deciding between assisted living facilities and nursing homes, consider your loved one’s specific needs. If they require medical care and supervision, a nursing home may be the best option. If they are relatively independent but still need some help with daily activities, an assisted living facility might be a better option.
You should also visit these facilities, meet the staff, and observe the environment to make sure it feels like a good fit for your loved one. Also, inquire about the longevity of the administrator and the staff ratio. This, too, will help you make an informed decision. One last thing, it is highly advisable that you compare nursing homes in your area by viewing their “report card” through Medicare.gov’s care compare web page. This comparison tool will provide you with a snapshot of all the nursing facilities in your area before visiting.
Choosing the right care setting can greatly impact your loved one’s quality of life. By understanding the differences between nursing homes and assisted living facilities, you can find the best option to meet their needs and provide them with the support they deserve. Good luck on your journey!
Dr. Macie P. Smith is a licensed gerontology social worker who is focused on helping families support their aging loved ones through long-term care. Specifically, Dr. Smith educates caregivers on how to care for seniors with dementia. She is an advocate for specialized care and assists others in finding a way to provide a better quality of life for individuals with Alzheimer’s or dementia. Dr. Smith has dedicated over 22 years of her life working in gerontology and assisting families in finding personalized solutions for dementia care. For more articles by Dr. Macie Smith, click here.
___________
SYNERGY HomeCare offers no obligation home assessments. Find a location near you or contact us to learn how we can help.
